The Australian Law Reform Commission says good surrogacy laws should enable responsible family-building and provide effective safeguards against exploitation and harm. According to ABC Australia, the ALRC said its proposals would address state and territory laws that made surrogacy difficult and could leave surrogates financially worse off.
Justice Mordy Bromberg said Australia’s laws drove intended parents overseas, exposing children, surrogates and parents to risks of harm and exploitation. According to ABC Australia, the attorney-general asked the ALRC in 2024 to examine surrogacy laws and practices, including children’s rights and recognition of overseas arrangements.
According to The Guardian, the commission said inconsistent laws and criminal sanctions drove parents overseas and arrangements underground, reducing visibility and increasing risks. The report proposed broader payments for surrogates, covering medical costs, lost earnings including superannuation, birth support and other pregnancy-related expenses.
According to ABC Australia, the ALRC proposed a monthly pregnancy payment, capped by a proposed regulator, to compensate for physical and psychological impacts without making arrangements commercial. The commission said state and territory reimbursement rules varied and did not let surrogates recover all financial and non-financial losses.
According to The Guardian, Estimates cited in the report showed domestic gestational surrogacy births increased from 27 in 2014 to 84 in 2023. According to ABC Australia, the ALRC estimated more than 300 Australian children were born through overseas surrogacy annually, about four in five Australian surrogacy births.
According to ABC Australia, At birth, the surrogate and, depending on state law, her partner are legal parents; intended parents must obtain a court order to transfer parentage. The Federal Circuit and Family Court supported automatic parentage, saying it would reflect the parties’ intentions and let intended parents make welfare decisions after birth.
According to ABC Australia, the report recommended a National Surrogacy Register, allowing children from age 16 to access recorded information about their surrogate’s birth details. The commission found that most states and territories lacked a system for children born through surrogacy to learn who gave birth to them.
According to ABC Australia, the commission cited an intended parent who said restrictive laws led them to seek a surrogate through a Facebook post after four years. The inquiry received more than 460 submissions from people with surrogacy experience, community groups and government departments.
According to ABC Australia, Religious groups said separating a child from the gestational mother violated rights to biological and emotional bonds; Equality Australia said restrictions disproportionately affected LGBTQ+ families and single parents. The federal government said states and territories had primary regulatory responsibility and it would consider recommendations with them; it had no current plans for legislative changes.
According to The Guardian, the report recommended regulated overseas surrogacy, and ALRC legal officer Jacinth Pathmanathan said intended parents would need registration, official guidance and legal advice in both countries. Pathmanathan said rules would require reasonable steps to avoid unlawful arrangements, those below Australian requirements or posing significant risk; breaches could carry civil penalties.
Reader comments (0)
Bring evidence, ask questions, or challenge our reporting. Every comment is checked before publication.
No approved comments yet
Be the first to ask a thoughtful question or contribute useful context. We won't invent reader conversations.
Join the discussion
Members-only commenting
Everyone can read comments. To write, verify your email and sign in to your free member account.
Sign in or join freeNo newsletter subscription is required. Your email address remains private.