Amazon Web Services CEO Matt Garman said orbital data centers are unlikely to be economically workable or practical over the coming decade or two. According to Newsweek, On the Sources Podcast, Garman described orbital data centers as unlikely to become practical or economically feasible soon, repeating his doubts about their near-term prospects.

According to Business Insider, Garman said on the Sources Podcast that he considered orbital data centers highly unlikely to be economically feasible or practical within the next decade or two. SpaceX said earlier this year it aimed to build a constellation of one million satellites operating as orbital data centers and had begun hiring engineers for the effort.

According to Business Insider, In January, Elon Musk said space could become the cheapest place for data centers within three years at the latest. Jeff Bezos called space data centers very realistic in a May CNBC interview, while saying timelines of two or three years were probably ambitious.

According to Newsweek, Blue Origin’s filing with the Federal Communications Commission described orbital data centers as a complement to terrestrial infrastructure, offering a computing tier independent of Earth-based constraints, but provided no timeline. SpaceX CFO Bret Johnsen said the company was on target to fly its first orbital compute satellite in 2027, and SpaceX sought FCC approval for as many as one million solar-powered satellites.

According to Newsweek, Google’s Project Suncatcher aims to test whether space can support machine-learning infrastructure able to handle large-scale AI workloads in orbit. Karen Howard of the Government Accountability Office said large orbital facilities would need power, cooling and advanced data-transfer systems designed to avoid excessive size or launch weight.

According to Newsweek, Aurelia Institute CEO Ariel Ekblaw said space systems would need cooling mechanisms, radiation-resistant electronics and infrastructure for updating equipment as chipmakers upgrade products. The ICEF report recommended postponing large-scale deployments until risk assessments and impact reports were completed, regulatory frameworks established and adequate protections put in place.

According to Newsweek, ICEF proposed an international space-traffic authority to track and regulate deployments, reduce collision risks, and guard against monopolized control and abuses. ICEF estimated that meeting 10 percent of projected 2030 AI demand with orbital data centers would require at least 700 Starship-sized launches each year.

According to Newsweek, the report also identified falling debris, waste disposal, fuel emissions, interference with observation and research, and unforeseen consequences as potential concerns. According to Business Insider, Garman said locating data centers far from communities could leave towns without the tax base and high-paying jobs such facilities can bring.

According to Business Insider, Garman pushed back on concerns about data-center water use, saying Amazon’s largest facilities use less water than 40 U.S. households.