Conservative Supreme Court justices appeared receptive on Nov. 3 to Catholic preschools challenging Colorado’s conditions for public funding, Fox News reported after oral arguments. The schools contend that requiring them to admit children from LGBTQ+ families infringes their religious freedom; Colorado says participating schools must follow the same nondiscrimination rules.
The dispute concerns Colorado’s universal preschool program, created through a 2020 ballot measure. It offers an annual benefit of $6,300 per child for up to 15 hours of preschool each week. The Catholic institutions seek an exemption from requirements they say conflict with their teachings on same-sex relationships and gender identity.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh questioned why Colorado could not accommodate religious schools while preserving options for LGBTQ+ families. Justice Amy Coney Barrett asked whether imposing a condition Catholic schools cannot accept differs from excluding them explicitly. But Chief Justice John Roberts noted that earlier school-funding cases involved laws that expressly singled out religious institutions.
Liberal justices emphasized the children affected by the admissions policies. Justice Sonia Sotomayor challenged the schools’ demand for public subsidies while retaining the ability to reject those families. Justice Elena Kagan questioned whether the requested exemption would give religious institutions preferential treatment rather than equal treatment.
The Associated Press reported that the plaintiffs also point to admissions preferences allowed for children with disabilities or from low-income families. They argue that religiously based admissions should likewise be permitted. Colorado disputes that comparison, saying the other preferences comply with its nondiscrimination rules.
The case could further narrow a 1990 Supreme Court precedent holding that religious practices do not create exemptions from broadly applicable laws, according to AP. The Trump administration supports the Catholic institutions. Fox reported that a ruling is expected by spring 2027; the justices’ questions do not settle the outcome.
Reader comments (0)
Bring evidence, ask questions, or challenge our reporting. Every comment is checked before publication.
No approved comments yet
Be the first to ask a thoughtful question or contribute useful context. We won't invent reader conversations.
Join the discussion
Members-only commenting
Everyone can read comments. To write, verify your email and sign in to your free member account.
Sign in or join freeNo newsletter subscription is required. Your email address remains private.