Four defendants in a Cornell University rape lawsuit joined a bid to remove Attorney General Letitia James from the probe. The four men agreed to add their names to a pre-existing petition requesting James’ removal, citing her prior supportive social media post about the alleged victim.

According to GlobalNews Canada, Lawyers for the men argue that James’ social media comments suggest she cannot remain impartial, presenting a substantial likelihood of prejudice if she stays on the case. Andrew Miltenberg, attorney for the lead defendant seeking James' removal, said that appointing Kelly changes the public face of the investigation but does not alter James’ ultimate oversight as attorney general.

A judge last week refrained from ruling on removing James until determining whether the remaining six defendants would also join the petition, giving lawyers a Thursday deadline for signatures. Four of those six defendants agreed to the removal effort, including one whose counsel had previously filed separately for James' removal; two others neither responded nor had legal representation.

The petition to remove James followed a September lawsuit by a former Cornell student known as Jane Doe, alleging she was gang raped by several fraternity members at an on-campus party in 2024. Jane Doe claimed in the filing that she was pressured into consuming ketamine and marijuana, after drinking alcohol, which left her unable to consent.

Court documents also state that not all the men named as defendants in the lawsuit were accused of rape.