Google education vice president Chris Phillips said the company believes schools should control classroom AI, with a goal of giving school leaders authority over how it is used. According to CBS News, under the policy described by CBS, schools that did not also provide Google education apps such as Classroom would lose Search access for student accounts.

According to CBS News, Google said its AI features are so closely integrated into Search that it cannot offer Search without also enabling AI services. An Alphabet spokesperson said the policy was intended to give schools more control over how they allowed AI into schools.

According to CBS News, Sen. Edward Markey said Google should not use its dominance in education technology to push schools toward its tools by limiting access to research resources. Markey asked whether Google would let schools disable AI features and chatbots on K-12 accounts while keeping Search available to students.

According to CBS News, He also requested disclosure of Google research or testing on AI safety and the effects of its AI functions on K-12 students’ mental health. According to The Independent, the lawsuit reportedly alleged that the girl’s school blocked Gemini’s standalone app and website, but she accessed the chatbot through Google Search.

According to CBS News, Markey said schools faced a choice between exposing students to potentially dangerous AI and depriving them of an important educational research tool. According to The Independent, Massachusetts Teachers Association president Matt Bach told NBC10 Boston educators did not want AI in classrooms and accused Google of using its monopoly status.

The policy controversy emerged amid a broader battle over technology in U.S. schools, the Independent reported. Illinois Superintendent Hank Thiele told NPR Google had previously been a good district partner and said the policy could damage built-up trust.