The origins of the lawsuit are Garcia’s statements on national television, in which he alleged that Black was a central figure in Epstein’s crimes and directly involved with Epstein’s trafficking network. According to The Guardian, Garcia alleged that Black was among the last people to have contact with Jeffrey Epstein before Epstein’s death in jail in 2019.

Garcia said on television that he spoke with survivors who credibly identified Black as being involved in direct abuse of women and in activities with Epstein. Black’s lawsuit contends that Garcia’s statements were false, made with malice, and resulted in significant harm to Black.

According to The Guardian, as of 5 November, the Department of Justice had not brought contempt charges against Black for issues related to congressional subpoenas. This lawsuit was filed after the House approved a resolution to hold Black in contempt of Congress for defying Oversight Committee subpoenas during its investigation into Epstein.

Black participated voluntarily in an interview with the Oversight Committee in June, during which he denied any knowledge of Epstein’s sex trafficking network. According to Black and his attorneys, he repeatedly denied any wrongdoing and asserted that he had no knowledge of Epstein’s criminal conduct.

According to The Guardian, After that voluntary interview, the hearing ended abruptly when Black refused to answer questions regarding nondisclosure agreements. Black did not attend a scheduled deposition on September 3 and did not provide all the nondisclosure agreements sought by the committee.

According to The Guardian, Black argued that releasing the nondisclosure agreements to comply with the subpoena would risk exposing women who value privacy and have no known public connection to Epstein. According to both outlets, Garcia’s office did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the lawsuit.

According to ABC Politics, In September, Garcia described the contempt resolution against Black as an important step toward justice and accountability. According to The Guardian, During September, Garcia also alleged that Black funded Epstein’s abuse and trafficking of women, and claimed that multiple women had accused Black of sexual assault.

According to The Guardian, a spokesperson for Black stated that Black has never abused a woman, has never been with an underage woman, has never been involved in sex trafficking, and has never paid Epstein for women. According to ABC Politics, Black is the co-founder of Apollo Global Management and stepped down in 2021 amid fallout concerning his connections to Epstein.

According to The Guardian, the New York Times reported that Black paid Epstein $170 million between 2013 and 2017 for tax and estate planning services. According to ABC Politics, Women who survived Epstein’s alleged sexual abuse have testified that they were trafficked as young women by Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.

According to The Guardian, During a news conference, Garcia said the Oversight Committee would focus on four issues, including Epstein, beginning in January.