Victoria Police said it would not proceed with criminal charges against the players after a thorough investigation and legal advice, citing insufficient evidence. According to The Independent, After the Swans beat Essendon on 17 August, women believed to be adult entertainers were reportedly hired and joined players at their hotel afterward.

Police said it could not comment further because a civil matter related to the incident remained ongoing. According to The Independent, the Swans suspended the four players and teammate Riley Bice for violating club standards, including drinking and taking women back to their hotel after the game.

The players denied wrongdoing but apologized for drinking and inviting women back to the hotel after a game, actions they acknowledged breached the club’s standards. Police had already cleared Riley Bice, the fifth suspended player, of any wrongdoing in the matter, according to the BBC report.

According to The Independent, Lawyer Pannam said his client reported the incident immediately, gave police a formal statement and cooperated fully with the investigation. John Karantzis of Carbone Lawyers said his two clients were very disappointed and distressed by the outcome.

Karantzis said the women’s civil claim used the balance of probabilities, a standard of proof distinct from the one applied in criminal proceedings. According to BBC, Heeney welcomed the police announcement, saying the preceding three months had been incredibly difficult for his family, fiancée and others close to him.

According to The Independent, Swans chief executive Matthew Pavlich said the club had stayed in constant contact with the players throughout the process, which he described as difficult for those involved and affected. Swans management said the players’ conduct fell short of the behaviour standards expected at the club, and said it stood by its decision to expel the player.

The club said it had begun a comprehensive examination of its AFL program and would act on the findings to implement meaningful change. According to BBC, Pavlich said the announcement was not a day for anyone to celebrate, adding that the club was still scrutinizing its program to identify areas needing improvement.

According to BBC, In a separate statement, the AFL noted the police decision and said it could still investigate if additional relevant information came to light. The Independent reported that Blakey had joined North Melbourne the previous month and apologized for the events that led to his departure from Sydney.

According to The Independent, Blakey said he knew he needed to regain the trust of the broader community, including people in football and outside the sport.