Researchers comparing test scores at schools that adopted locked-phone pouches with similar schools that did not found modest academic gains associated with the restrictions. The student-level analysis covered 844 schools using Yondr pouches and tests administered by NWEA, NPR reported.

According to NPR, Typically, schools required students to place phones in pouches at the start of the school day, returning them after administrators unlocked them with magnetic devices. Researchers said the gains appeared to persist for as long as three years after adoption, rather than disappearing after the first year.

The newer study had not undergone peer review, while an April study that found no meaningful overall gains had been peer-reviewed, NPR reported. That April research combined average school-level test scores from several thousand schools using Yondr pouches, unlike the newer study’s student-level analysis.

NPR said the April research covered a larger sample of schools, while the newer study provided more detailed data about individual students. The April study found statistically significant gains in high-school math, offset by learning losses related to phone bans in middle school, co-author Brian Jacob said.

According to The Guardian, Dee described early results from school phone bans as largely disappointing and said important questions about their effects remained unresolved. Kane said researchers could not investigate suspected effects of late-night social-media use because companies had not shared platform-use data linked to student outcomes.

According to NPR, Kane estimated the pouches cost schools about $25 per student and argued that was less than paying teachers for an extra week or two of instruction. NPR reported that math achievement among fourth- and eighth-graders rose from 1990 to 2013, then test scores declined through the pandemic period.

Research cited by NPR indicated reading scores had begun declining four to six years before the COVID-19 pandemic. NPR reported smartphone access among teen students rose from fewer than one-quarter in 2011 to 95% in 2018.