New research from the AARP Public Policy Institute found that the share of the U.S. economy subject to Social Security payroll taxes has declined substantially over the past four decades. According to CNBC, the report estimated Social Security would have collected an additional $10.8 trillion between 1984 and 2034 if taxable payroll had remained at 41% of GDP.
According to CNBC, AARP estimated that maintaining that share could have supported full benefits through 2059, 25 years beyond the combined funds’ projected depletion in 2034. Payroll taxes supplied 91% of Social Security revenue in 2025, while interest income provided 5% and federal income taxes on benefits contributed about 4%, AARP data showed.
According to Newsweek, In 2026, Social Security payroll taxes applied to the first $184,500 of wages, with the taxable maximum scheduled to rise to $192,300 in 2027. According to CNBC, AARP’s analysis also cited automation’s reduction of demand for workers and pass-through businesses that let some owners report compensation as profits instead of wages.
According to CNBC, Only about 6% of individuals had earnings at or above the taxable maximum in 2024, AARP reported, meaning an increase would not affect most workers. AARP said a new 12.4% tax on investment income for active S corporation officers and limited partners could close about 25% of the program’s 75-year financing gap.
According to CNBC, the trustees estimated that raising the combined payroll tax rate from 12.4% to 16.65% beginning in January 2026 would balance the program over the 75-year projection period. AARP vice president Richard Johnson said Social Security’s finances weakened not only as the population aged, but because the economy changed while its revenue system did not.
According to CNBC, AARP vice president Jenn Jones said the organization opposed cuts to monthly checks, adding that many Americans could not afford to lose any benefit income. The 1983 reforms gradually increased the retirement age from 65 to 67, delayed cost-of-living adjustments by six months and taxed Social Security benefits.
Kevin Thompson of 9i Capital Group told Newsweek that higher payroll taxes could improve long-term solvency but were politically unpopular and might be viewed as regressive. Financial literacy instructor Alex Beene told Newsweek that studies indicated growing openness to higher payroll taxes if they preserved Social Security.
Reader comments (0)
Bring evidence, ask questions, or challenge our reporting. Every comment is checked before publication.
No approved comments yet
Be the first to ask a thoughtful question or contribute useful context. We won't invent reader conversations.
Join the discussion
Members-only commenting
Everyone can read comments. To write, verify your email and sign in to your free member account.
Sign in or join freeNo newsletter subscription is required. Your email address remains private.