Sen. Ron Johnson said Social Security benefits are paid with contributions from younger generations and money borrowed from the public. According to Fox News, a report by Johnson projects that Social Security will face insolvency in 2032, alongside a shortfall of roughly $511 billion that year.
According to Fox News, Johnson said current law would reduce benefits when Social Security’s trust fund is depleted, which his report estimates will happen in 2032. His report places the projected $511 billion Social Security shortfall against a total federal deficit of $2.4 trillion projected for 2032.
According to MS NOW, Before a Senate Budget Committee hearing on Social Security’s future, Johnson went on Newsmax and again likened the program to a Ponzi scheme. Johnson described the Securities and Exchange Commission’s definition as an investment paying early investors with current investors’ money, then claimed Social Security operated that way.
According to Fox News, Johnson’s report argued that Americans had come to regard Social Security and their payroll contributions as a retirement account that grows over time. He said payroll money had already been spent on current beneficiaries or other government programs, while future benefits would depend on workers’ contributions and borrowing.
According to Fox News, Johnson blamed past congressional decisions, including not investing Social Security surpluses in stocks and promising costlier benefits when relatively few workers were in the workforce. He acknowledged Social Security could not be fixed as a retirement investment fund because, in his view, it had never been one.
According to Fox News, Johnson urged Congress to repeal the provision reducing benefits after trust-fund depletion and to address federal debt and deficits. According to MS NOW, During his 2022 reelection campaign, Johnson told voters Social Security was set up improperly and its funds would have been better invested in the stock market.
According to MS NOW, That campaign year, Johnson said he wanted Social Security moved into Congress’ discretionary budget, where benefits could face annual cuts. MS NOW reported that moving Social Security into the discretionary budget would end its guaranteed and automatic benefits.
According to MS NOW, Democrats used Johnson’s 2022 remarks against him, portraying the Wisconsin Republican as an opponent of a popular social insurance program. Johnson nevertheless won reelection in 2022 by one percentage point, despite Democrats’ criticism of his Social Security position.
According to MS NOW, a Bipartisan Policy Center poll commissioned last year found that 93% of Americans considered Social Security a valuable federal program. MS NOW described Social Security as the country’s most popular program, based on the poll’s finding that 93% of Americans valued it.
Fox News described Johnson as Senate Budget Committee chair for another two months when reporting on his new report. MS NOW said Johnson’s recent statements could give opponents material ahead of his likely 2028 reelection campaign.
Reader comments (0)
Bring evidence, ask questions, or challenge our reporting. Every comment is checked before publication.
No approved comments yet
Be the first to ask a thoughtful question or contribute useful context. We won't invent reader conversations.
Join the discussion
Members-only commenting
Everyone can read comments. To write, verify your email and sign in to your free member account.
Sign in or join freeNo newsletter subscription is required. Your email address remains private.