A federal appeals court ruled Friday that the Transportation Department wrongly withheld highway funds from New York over commercial driver licenses issued to foreign drivers. According to US News, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said USDOT exceeded its authority when it withheld $73.5 million from New York.

According to PBS NewsHour, a three-judge panel in Manhattan found the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration acted arbitrarily, capriciously, or contrary to law, according to its written decision. The court said rules requiring cancellation when a commercial driver lost legal U.S. status were not in place at the time.

According to US News, USDOT cited an audit finding that New York had routinely issued commercial licenses to foreign drivers illegally. According to PBS NewsHour, New York authorities said the state issued licenses valid for eight years, regardless of how long a driver’s visa remained valid.

According to PBS NewsHour, Audits in every state found numerous non-domiciled licenses that remained valid after work permits expired or were issued without proper citizenship-status verification. New York Attorney General Letitia James said when the lawsuit was filed that federal withholding unfairly deprived the state of money needed for road and bridge repairs.

According to PBS NewsHour, the Transportation Department said allowing trucking licenses to outlast drivers’ lawful U.S. status by years made no sense and said its actions protected public safety. The department began enforcing existing English-language requirements for truckers in summer 2025.

According to PBS NewsHour, Immigrants make up about 20% of truck drivers, while non-domiciled licenses account for about 5% of commercial licenses, or roughly 200,000 drivers. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy tightened rules governing when immigrants may obtain commercial driver licenses.

According to PBS NewsHour, Duffy said a truck driver from India accused of an illegal U-turn in a fatal Florida crash should never have been licensed. The Florida crash occurred in August 2025 and killed three people; the driver was accused of making an illegal U-turn.