A California appeals court decided the lawsuit from Michael Crichton's widow and estate, claiming 'The Pitt' is an unapproved reboot of 'ER', can move forward. Noah Wyle, John Wells, and R. Scott Gemmill were removed as defendants due to the lack of evidence they knew Michael Crichton's contract details. TribLive reports that the court highlighted resemblances between 'ER' and 'The Pitt', such as both featuring an emergency room setting, rapid pacing, abundant medical jargon, graphic injury visuals, and a young, inept doctor just out of medical school.

Michael Crichton's contract with Warner Bros. Television had a 'frozen rights' clause restricting sequels, remakes, spinoffs, or any adaptations of 'ER' unless he or his estate approved. CBS News reports that sherri Crichton filed her lawsuit two years ago, before 'The Pitt' aired, asserting that 'The Pitt' was a relabeled and unauthorized 'ER' reboot she had already rejected.