Canada’s Supreme Court heard arguments challenging the federal prohibition on hundreds of firearm makes and models, putting cabinet’s authority to impose the measure before the country’s highest court. According to GlobalNews Canada, the federal prohibition took effect in May 2020, barring the use, sale and importation of about 1,500 firearm models and variants.
According to CBC, the challengers dispute whether cabinet, acting through an order of the Governor in Council, had legal authority to prohibit the firearms. The Criminal Code prevents cabinet from using regulations to outlaw a firearm it considers reasonable for hunting or sporting purposes.
According to GlobalNews Canada, a Federal Court judge dismissed a challenge in October 2023, ruling the prohibition was neither unlawful nor beyond the powers delegated to cabinet. In the earlier appeal, Chief Justice Yves de Montigny said public-safety concerns could inform whether firearms were reasonable for hunting or sport, including their lethality and potential to cause mass casualties.
According to GlobalNews Canada, De Montigny also pointed to firearms’ use in mass shootings in Canada and abroad, their disproportionate nature for civilian use, and growing demand for measures addressing gun violence. In its Supreme Court submission, the federal government argued cabinet reasonably exercised its broad discretion because the firearms presented serious public-safety concerns.
According to GlobalNews Canada, Federal lawyers cited a regulatory impact analysis saying some hunters and sport shooters had lawfully used the firearms, but they could increase the severity of mass shootings. The federal submission estimated that firearms prohibited in 2020 were owned by three to five per cent of Canadian firearm owners.
According to GlobalNews Canada, the government also argued that thousands of other firearms remained legally available for hunting and sporting use. The appellants argued that the lower courts failed to consider whether the newly prohibited firearms were actually used for hunting or sport shooting.
According to GlobalNews Canada, Their submission said Parliament recognized hunting and sport shooting as legitimate, lawful and socially accepted uses of firearms, while acknowledging that misuse threatened public safety. The appellants said law-abiding owners, including hunters, collectors and small businesses, lost lawful use of prohibited property and faced potential criminal liability.
According to CBC, They described affected people as including farmers, veterans, competitive athletes and Indigenous harvesters in communities across Canada. Before the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case, the government set October 30 as the deadline for owners to dispose of or deactivate prohibited firearms.
The government later extended the amnesty until 90 days after the Supreme Court delivers its decision. According to CBC, In recent months, owners who declared a prohibited firearm were asked to surrender it if they wanted compensation.
The federal government had not answered CBC’s question about how many firearms it collected.
Reader comments (0)
Bring evidence, ask questions, or challenge our reporting. Every comment is checked before publication.
No approved comments yet
Be the first to ask a thoughtful question or contribute useful context. We won't invent reader conversations.
Join the discussion
Members-only commenting
Everyone can read comments. To write, verify your email and sign in to your free member account.
Sign in or join freeNo newsletter subscription is required. Your email address remains private.