Puerto Rico native Roberto Clemente played 18 seasons for Major League Baseball’s Pittsburgh Pirates, from 1955 to 1972. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear his sons’ challenge to Puerto Rico’s use of Clemente’s image on commemorative license plates and vehicle registration tags.

The justices turned away an appeal by Clemente’s three sons after lower courts rejected their claims against Puerto Rico. His sons alleged that using Clemente’s likeness on commemorative plates and registration tags violated constitutional protections against government taking of trademark rights.

Puerto Rico issued the commemorative plates and registration tags featuring Clemente’s image in 2022 without permission from his sons. According to US News, Puerto Rico ended the vehicle-plate and registration-tag program at the end of 2022.

The lawsuit named the government of Puerto Rico, Roberto Clemente Jr., Luis Roberto Clemente, Roberto Enrique Clemente and two companies owned by the sons. According to US News, the sons said their companies work to protect the Roberto Clemente trademark, preserve his legacy and promote his philanthropy.

The lawsuit alleged that Puerto Rico’s use of Clemente’s likeness generated $15 million and sought to block future use on plates and tags. The sons also sought $45 million in damages and an additional $3.15 million in compensation for trademark infringement.

U.S. District Judge Gina Mendez-Miro, based in San Juan, dismissed the case; the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals partially affirmed that dismissal. The 1st Circuit rejected the sons’ claim that Puerto Rico’s use of the trademarks amounted to an unconstitutional government taking.

In their Supreme Court filing, the sons’ lawyers argued that lower courts wrongly denied trademarks automatic Fifth Amendment protection as intangible property. According to The Independent, the family’s lawyers distinguished trademarks from tangible property, citing land and real estate in their argument about constitutional protection.

According to US News, the sons’ lawyers warned that the 1st Circuit ruling could allow governments to take trademarks under a balancing test that might leave some value uncompensated. Puerto Rico argued that the 1st Circuit had not categorically excluded intangible property from automatic Fifth Amendment protection.

Puerto Rico said the appeals court instead resolved the issues by applying existing precedent to the facts of this case. Clemente, a Puerto Rico native, played 18 seasons for Major League Baseball’s Pittsburgh Pirates from 1955 to 1972.

He was a 15-time All-Star and two-time World Series champion, and was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Clemente died at age 38 in a 1972 airplane crash while delivering humanitarian aid to earthquake victims in Nicaragua.