Lawyers asked the court of appeal to move Henry Nowak’s killer’s minimum prison term in opposite directions on November 5, The Guardian reported. Attorney general Ellie Reeves is challenging the sentence as unduly lenient, while Vickrum Digwa argues it is excessive.

Digwa, 23, received a life sentence in June with a minimum of 21 years for murdering Nowak, an 18-year-old student, in Southampton in December 2025. The minimum term is not a fixed release date.

Jonathan Polnay KC, representing Reeves, argued that the punishment did not adequately reflect Digwa’s false accusations of racism against Nowak, efforts to conceal evidence and filming of the dying victim. He also said Digwa’s lethal use of a dagger carried under a religious exemption deserved particular weight, distinguishing that conduct from lawful possession of a Sikh kirpan.

Digwa’s barrister, Imran Khan KC, countered that the sentencing judge had already accounted for the weapon and abuse of religious privilege. He warned against counting the same conduct repeatedly. Khan acknowledged that Digwa’s lies affected Nowak’s dignity, but said his injuries were unsurvivable and the false account had not deprived him of a chance to live.

Separately, the BBC reported the family’s anger at both Digwa’s appeal and the expected early release of his mother, Kiran Kaur. In interviews with ITV News, Nowak’s stepmother, Katie Nowak, described the appeal as another painful legal battle, while his father, Mark Nowak, condemned Kaur’s anticipated December release.

Kaur was sentenced to three years for assisting an offender after hiding the murder weapon. The BBC reported that she would remain on licence after release and could be recalled for breaching its conditions. The Guardian’s November 5 report said the hearing was due to conclude that day; it reported no ruling.