The Supreme Court’s conservative majority appeared inclined during arguments Tuesday, Nov. 3, to support Catholic preschools seeking Colorado funding while retaining the ability to reject children of gay and transgender parents, NPR reported. The justices had not issued a decision.
The dispute centers on whether Colorado’s equal-access conditions violate religious freedom. The Guardian reported before the hearing that two Catholic preschools brought the challenge, St Mary Catholic Parish v Roy. They argue that requiring them to accept the state’s enrollment rules as a condition of funding unlawfully penalizes their religious beliefs.
Colorado maintains that religious schools are welcome in the program if they follow the same nondiscrimination requirements as other participating providers. According to the Guardian, an appeals court sided with the state, distinguishing its rules from policies that categorically exclude religious institutions from public funding. NPR noted that Catholic Charities continues to participate.
During the hearing, Justice Brett Kavanaugh suggested that families could choose among other preschools while Catholic schools received an accommodation. Justice Samuel Alito questioned whether there was evidence that LGBTQ parents could not find alternatives, NPR reported.
Colorado Deputy Solicitor General Helen Norton countered by citing a rejected student and arguing that preschools are not interchangeable. Families may need particular opening hours to reach work or a school able to accommodate several siblings.
The three liberal justices challenged the requested exemption. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson questioned how exclusion based on parents’ sexuality could be distinguished in principle from racial exclusion. NPR described Chief Justice John Roberts as the only conservative justice to express skepticism about the archdiocese’s position. A ruling is expected by summer 2027.
Reader comments (0)
Bring evidence, ask questions, or challenge our reporting. Every comment is checked before publication.
No approved comments yet
Be the first to ask a thoughtful question or contribute useful context. We won't invent reader conversations.
Join the discussion
Members-only commenting
Everyone can read comments. To write, verify your email and sign in to your free member account.
Sign in or join freeNo newsletter subscription is required. Your email address remains private.